Gulf Shore Colony Club Redevelopment – A New Chapter for 1785 Gulf Shore Blvd N

Set along one of the most prized stretches of beachfront in Naples, the former Gulf Shore Colony Club in The Moorings is quietly preparing for a major transformation. Once a quaint mid-century co-op, this irreplaceable Gulf-front site at 1785 Gulf Shore Blvd N is now poised to become one of the most exciting ultra-luxury condo opportunities in Southwest Florida.

What Was Gulf Shore Colony Club?

Originally built in 1960, Gulf Shore Colony Club consisted of six two-story buildings with just 16 condos total—each residence ranging from approximately 1,400 to 1,800 square feet. The co-op was known for its vintage charm, low density, and direct beachfront access in the heart of The Moorings.

Sadly, like many older coastal properties, it sustained major damage during Hurricane Ian in 2023 and was eventually sold to new developers.

The Site Today: A Rare Beachfront Canvas

The 2.1-acre site has since been cleared of all existing structures by its new owners, the Youngquist Brothers, a respected family-run business based in Fort Myers. Known for their diverse commercial holdings across Florida—including construction, rock mining, and real estate development—the Youngquist Brothers bring deep experience and vision to the table.

While details are still emerging, we know the proposed plan includes a seven-story building over parking with 24 high-end residences, reaching up to 75 feet above flood elevation (with allowances for additional height for architectural features, mechanicals, and elevator towers). The project is currently in the City of Naples review and approval process.

Why So Quiet?

Compared to other new developments along Gulf Shore Boulevard, public details about this one have been limited—likely a reflection of the soft real estate market during the 2020s real estate recession. With a more measured pace of buyer demand, developers are being strategic about timelines and marketing.

That said, the value of this rare beachfront parcel can’t be overstated. With direct Gulf views and walkability to coffee and brunch at Charleston Square, the finished residences will no doubt attract discerning buyers seeking exclusivity and timeless luxury.

Unbiased Representation for Buyers

As a Naples Realtor specializing in new construction and luxury waterfront properties, I offer unbiased representation to buyers considering opportunities like this. While I’m not affiliated with the developer, I provide insider-level insights, data-driven guidance, and skilled negotiation throughout the buying process from reservation to closing.

If you're curious about the future of this site, want to stay informed as approvals progress, or would like to explore other new developments nearby, I’d love to be your trusted advisor.

Want to Learn More?

As more details emerge about the redevelopment of 1785 Gulf Shore Blvd N, I’ll be sharing updates with my network. If you’d like to stay in the loop, reach out any time:

Call or text Melinda Gunther : 239-297-2155
Schedule a consultation or sign up for updates on my website

Let’s make your move to the beach a smart and stylish one.