The Top 5 Most Exclusive Neighborhoods in Grey Oaks, Naples

Grey Oaks Melinda Gunther June 30, 2025

When it comes to luxury country club living in Naples, Grey Oaks stands in a league of its own. Known for its three championship golf courses, resort-style amenities, and central location just minutes from the beach and Fifth Avenue South, Grey Oaks consistently ranks among the most prestigious private communities in Florida.

But within its gates, some neighborhoods are more exclusive than others offering oversized homesites, dramatic views, and a sense of privacy that appeals to Naples’ most discerning buyers. Here are the Top 5 Most Exclusive Neighborhoods in Grey Oaks.

1. Isle Royale – The Rarest of Them All

With just 19 estate-sized homes, Isle Royale is Grey Oaks’ most exclusive enclave. Each residence sits on an oversized lot with sweeping lake and golf views. Homes range from 4,000 to over 12,000 square feet, making them some of the largest in the community. Opportunities here are exceptionally rare, and every home is a statement of architectural elegance and privacy.

2. Estuary – 350 Acres of Gated Luxury

The Estuary at Grey Oaks is a separate 350-acre gated preserve featuring just 179 residences across cobblestone streets, lakes, and rolling fairways. Home styles range from custom estates over 10,000 square feet to villas and coach homes, blending Mediterranean elegance with transitional modern design. Residents also enjoy the Estuary Golf Course, a target-style course known for its beauty and challenge, alongside the Pine and Palm courses of Grey Oaks.

3. Banyan Island – Lakefront Serenity

An enclave of just 26 oversized homesites, Banyan Island is nearly surrounded by sparkling lakes, with many properties enjoying both water and golf course views. Homes here were built between 2000 and 2004, ranging from 3,400 to more than 6,000 square feet. Southern exposures and expansive outdoor living areas make this neighborhood a favorite for year-round entertaining.

4. Capistrano – Mediterranean Villa Charm

Capistrano offers an intimate collection of 21 Mediterranean-style villas with golf and lake views, many overlooking the 17th hole of the Palm Course. Built between 2001 and 2006, villas range from 3,000 to 3,600 square feet, with courtyards, lanais, and private pools. For buyers seeking exclusivity in a low-maintenance villa setting, Capistrano delivers both charm and sophistication.

5. Isla Vista – Villas with a Private Estate Feel

For those who want the convenience of villa living with the grandeur of an estate, Isla Vista is an exceptional choice. These Mediterranean-inspired residences feature spacious floor plans, private pools, and sweeping golf and lake views. With its central location and architectural detail, Isla Vista blends privacy with proximity to Grey Oaks’ main clubhouse and amenities.

Why Buyers Choose Grey Oaks

Grey Oaks is one of only two Naples clubs with three championship golf courses, consistently ranked among the best in Florida. Beyond golf, residents enjoy:

Two elegant clubhouses plus the intimate Estuary clubhouse.
Resort-style lagoon pool and cabanas.
Fitness and wellness center with spa services.
Har-Tru tennis, pickleball, and bocce courts.
A full calendar of dining, social, and cultural events.

Its central Naples location puts residents just minutes from Fifth Avenue South, Waterside Shops, Mercato, Artis-Naples, and pristine Gulf beaches.

Discover Grey Oaks’ Most Prestigious Homes

From the ultra-private estates of Isle Royale to the grand villas of Capistrano and Isla Vista, Grey Oaks offers a neighborhood to fit every vision of Naples luxury. These exclusive enclaves rarely see homes come on the market, making them true opportunities for buyers seeking something extraordinary.

Contact Melinda Gunther, Naples luxury real estate advisor, to explore available homes in Grey Oaks and discover the neighborhood that best fits your lifestyle.